Working With Us
The Biggest Mistakes Homeowners Make When Hiring a Carpenter
1 May 2026 · 6 min read
We get called to fix other people's carpentry more often than we'd like. The patterns are remarkably consistent: the same six mistakes show up in nearly every job that's gone sideways. None of them are about the trades themselves — they all happen before the first board is cut.
1. Choosing the Cheapest Quote
The cheapest quote is almost never the cheapest job. By the time variations, missed inclusions and corner-cutting on materials catch up, you've usually paid more than the second-cheapest quote — and you've lost months in the process.
A good rule: throw out the highest and lowest quotes, then choose between the rest based on scope clarity and rapport, not price.
"The cheapest quote always becomes the most expensive bill — usually halfway through the job, when there's nowhere left to turn."
2. Not Checking Previous Projects
A portfolio is easy to fake. References are not. Ask to see two completed projects in person if possible, or get the contact details of the last two clients and call them. Five minutes on the phone tells you more than fifty Instagram posts.
3. Vague Communication Expectations
If you don't agree how often you'll hear from your carpenter — and through which channel — the silence will become the source of every argument on the job. We commit to a weekly written update on every project, with photos and a clear list of decisions needed.
4. No Written Scope of Works
If the scope lives in someone's head, every change becomes a dispute. A proper written scope lists every inclusion, every exclusion, every nominated material and every assumption. It's boring to write and priceless to have when something gets queried in week six.
5. Ignoring Timber and Material Quality
Two carpenters can quote the same job and use timber that costs three times less per linear metre. The difference doesn't show up on day one — it shows up at year three when one deck is silvering beautifully and the other is cupping and splitting.
| Material grade | Typical use | Lifespan in QLD |
|---|---|---|
| Premium hardwood (spotted gum, blackbutt) | Decking, feature joinery, outdoor seating | 25+ years |
| Mid-grade hardwood (merbau) | Decking, screens | 15–20 years |
| Treated softwood | Hidden structural framing only | 10–15 years |
6. Hiring a General Handyman for Specialist Joinery
A great handyman is invaluable for the right job. Bespoke joinery is not that job. The skill set, tooling and workshop required for fitted carpentry is genuinely different — and the result of mismatching the two is usually visible within the first month.
Pros
- Specialist carpenters quote with proper inclusions, lead times and a written scope
- Workshop-built joinery is dimensionally accurate and finishes properly
- Material selection is matched to the use case, not just what's in stock
Cons
- General handymen often quote on time-and-materials with no fixed end
- Fitted joinery built on site rarely sits flush long-term
- Off-the-shelf timber chosen for price almost always underperforms
FAQ
Frequently asked questions.
What should a good carpentry quote include?
A fixed price, a written scope, named materials and finishes, a payment schedule tied to milestones, an estimated start and finish date, and the QBCC licence number.
How do I check a carpenter's licence in Queensland?
Search the QBCC online register using their licence number or business name. It takes 30 seconds and confirms they hold valid insurance.
Should I pay a deposit upfront?
A reasonable deposit (5–10%) to lock in workshop time is standard. Anything significantly higher should come with a clear materials schedule explaining what it covers.
Ready to start?
Let's design your project.
A free, no-obligation consultation across the Sunshine Coast & Hinterland.
Get a free quote
